Audio from Prof. William Spurlin's talk: What we know from the historical record - the persecution of lesbians and gay men under the Third Reich.
Prof. Spurlin is introduced by Dave Moskovitz. A special thank you to Prof. Spurlin and the Holocaust Centre of New Zealand for allowing us to record this event.
Summary
The event recorded at the Holocaust Centre of New Zealand on March 6th, 2016, featured a significant lecture by Professor William Spurlin, introduced by Dave Moskovitz. Spurlin's talk, titled "What We Know from the Historical Record - The Persecution of Lesbians and Gay Men under the Third Reich," explored the atrocities committed against homosexual individuals during Nazi Germany.
Spurlin, a professor at Brunel University London, possesses expertise intersecting queer studies, postcolonial studies, and critical and cultural theory. Their scholarly work spans across literary, cultural, and critical texts from the 19th to the 21st centuries. During the event, Spurlin addressed the marginalized state of homosexual persecution narratives within broader Holocaust scholarship and posed critical questions regarding the reasons for their frequent exclusion from mainstream historical discourse.
The lecture spotlighted the fundamental shift from Weimar Germany’s relative liberalism toward the repressive tactics of the Third Reich, which sought to solidify 'normal' gender roles and eliminate what they considered 'abnormal' sexual behavior. The Nazis' campaign to cleanse the Reich began with book burnings and bar raids targeting the gay and lesbian community. Central to their strategy was the enforcement of Paragraph 175 of the penal code, which was expanded to criminalize a broader range of same-sex activities between men.
While the criminalization and persecution of lesbians were not explicitly included in this code, Spurlin noted that their experiences under Nazism were no less subject to the climate of fear and intolerance of the time. Women deemed to resist or flout expected gender roles faced harassment and intimidation, and any perceived masculinity or lesbian relations were prosecuted under the more nebulous term 'asocial.'
Spurlin detailed the institutional backdrop to these persecutions, including the founding of the Reich Central Office for Combating Homosexuality and Abortion, highlighting the intersection of homosexuality, eugenics, and Nazi racial politics. Deportations of gay men to concentration camps resulted in extremely harsh conditions, forced medical experiments, and coercion – steps that underscored the systemic nature of homophobic terror under the Third Reich. Despite atrocious conditions, homophobia within Nazi ranks was also noted, with internal purges like the Night of the Long Knives revealing the lethal consequences of being both a member of the SA and homosexual.
The post-war period brought additional injustice to homosexual Holocaust survivors. The remainder of pre-war sentences were reinstated, and claims of reparation were denied due to the ongoing criminalization of homosexuality in German law. These continuities of injustice posed significant obstacles to understanding and recognizing the full extent of persecution in the historical record.
As the recording drew to a close, Spurlin emphasized the need for continued scholarship in Holocaust studies that incorporates a nuanced understanding of sexuality and gender. The aim is to expand the historiographical frame to include the complexities of homosexual persecution and gender politics. The lecture demonstrated the vital importance of recognizing and integrating these narratives in broader Holocaust research to challenge heteronormative frames of understanding that have shaped the past.
In conclusion, Spurlin’s lecture at the Holocaust Centre of New Zealand provided an insightful examination of the persecution of the LGBTQ+ community under Nazi Germany and underscored the importance of these narratives in broader historical discourse, as well as in informing contemporary society and culture.
This summary is created using Generative AI. Although it is based on the recording's transcription, it may contain errors or omissions. Click here to learn more about how this summary was created.
Tags
1910s, 1920s, 1930s, 1940s, 2010s, abortion, academia, academics, adolf hitler, adrienne rich, alfred kinsey, anal sex, anti-semitism, aotearoa new zealand, bars, berlin, bigotry, black triangle (nazi germany), brunel university london, christchurch, church, claudia schoppmann, concentration camp, dave moskovitz, days of masquerade: life stories of lesbian women during the third reich (book), diversity, erica rothschild, ernst rohm, eugenics, fantasy, fascism, femininity, gay, gender politics, germany, heinrich himmler, heteronormativity, holocaust centre of new zealand, homocaust, homoerotic, homosexual, homosocial, hypermasculinity, identity, indonesia, institut fur sexualwissenschaft, intersectionality, judaism, kinsey reports, kinsey scale (heterosexual - homosexual rating scale), kissing, language, latent homosexuality, lesbian, lost intimacies: rethinking homosexuality under national socialism (book), magnus hirschfeld, masculinity, masturbation, national socialism, nazi germany, nazism, new german women's movement, oppression, other, othering, paragraph 175, pedophilia, persecution, pink triangle (symbol), pornography, propaganda, queer, racial politics, racism, raids, raye freedman trust, rentboy, rule foundation, sex work, sexual dissidents, sexual orientation, sexuality, sterilisation, the holocaust, third reich, wellington, wellington jewish community centre, wellington pride festival (2016), william spurlin, world war 2
Tags (computer generated)
1950s, 1960s, 1970s, 1980s, 1990s, affection, africa, african american, alienation, animals, apartheid, archives, arrest, arts, austria, bear, belonging, binary, blood, books, bottom, building, bus, camp, canterbury, capital, capitalism, casting, change, children, citizenship, class, clothing, clubs, code, collaboration, community, conference, confidence, conformity, congregation, connections, consent, conservative, council, crime, culture, data, david, death, death penalty, depression, desire, deviant, difference, disability, donation, education, email, employment, escape, europe, events, execution, expectations, experimental, expression, face, failure, faith, family, fear, film, france, french, friends, future, gender, gender binary, gender studies, german, god, government, hair, harassment, hate, health, heterosexual, history, homer, homo, homophobia, hope, hospital, imperialism, imprisonment, intervention, intolerance, isolation, israel, italy, james baldwin, japan, jewish community, journal, justice, knowledge, law, leadership, letter, lgbt, liberation, library, listening, lived experience, london, los angeles, love, lover, mainstream, march, marriage, masculine, medications, medicine, memorial, michel foucault, military, morality, murder, muslims, narrative, nature, netherlands, normal, occupation, opportunity, orgasm, otago, pacific, paris, passive, people, philadelphia, plague, police, policy, politics, power, prevention, prison, prisoners, procreation, promiscuity, pronouns, public health, punishment, queen, race, rape, reading, records, relationships, religion, rent, representation, research, resistance, romantic, russia, san francisco, scholarship, school, seattle, separation, sex, sexual rights, ships, silence, social, socialism, sodomy, south africa, strength, study, stuff, subversion, support, surveillance, survivor, teaching, the edge, the other side, time, top, tourism, tradition, trust, uganda, understanding, unemployment, university, unnatural, urban, victim, video, violence, visibility, visual arts, voice, women, women's rights, work, writing, youth