Legal background

This summary focuses on the legal background of the LGBT communities in New Zealand, as presented by Dr. Alison Laurie in a 15-minute recording from January 12, 2011. The presentation was delivered in Wellington, Aotearoa New Zealand, and delves into the historical context and legal evolution of same-sex relationships in the nation.

The talk begins with a reflection on the societal norms regarding same-sex relations among the indigenous Maori population, prior to European contact. Research by Maori scholars indicates a general acceptance of same-sex relationships in traditional Maori culture, with the term "takatapui" referring to an intimate companion of the same sex. European observers from the 18th and 19th centuries noted the open nature of such relationships among Maori, suggesting an absence of prohibitions against them.

With the arrival of whalers and sealers from Europe, as well as missionaries, the societal landscape began to change. The establishment of British law in New Zealand, especially after the Treaty of Waitangi in 1840 and the English Laws Act of 1858, imported restrictive colonial attitudes towards same-sexuality. The British legislation criminalized sexual acts between men, known as buggery or sodomy, with penalties ranging from 10 years to life imprisonment. Death penalties for these acts had been abolished just four years prior to the treaty in 1836.

Laurie further highlights that the criminalization of same-sex relations between men has roots in British laws enforced since Henry VIII's reign, initially serving as a means to confiscate monastic property. However, there were no laws against female same-sex relations, possibly due to the perception of women's activities as inconsequential or the misguided belief that without penetration, no real sexual activity occurred. Another reason suggested is the concern among British lawmakers that legal mention of lesbianism might encourage such behavior among women.

New Zealand's legal framework mirrored British laws for a considerable period, punishing same-sex acts between males with severe penalties, including life imprisonment, hard labor, and flogging—though flogging was removed in 1941 and hard labor in 1954. The absence of discussion around the decriminalization of homosexuality in New Zealand contrasted with Britain's Sexual Offenses Act of 1967, which decriminalized same-sex acts under certain conditions.

The 1961 New Zealand Crimes Act, whilst reducing penalties for homosexual acts, introduced a gendered dimension by criminalizing sexual relations between women over 21 and girls under 16, which marked the legal recognition of lesbianism and set a concerning precedent for possible legal manipulation.

During the 1960s, as the baby boom generation came of age, there was increased questioning of established norms, including those relating to same-sex relationships. Conversations around the Homosexual Law Reform became part of the national dialogue, setting the stage for Laurie's continued discussions on the topic.

This summary is created using Generative AI. Although it is based on the recording's transcription, it may contain errors or omissions. Click here to learn more about how this summary was created.

Alison Laurie

activism, alison laurie, courts, gay liberation movement, gay line wellington trust, history, human rights, politics, queer history 101, rule foundation, transcript online

1960s, abuse, acceptance, activities, age of consent, army, attitude, australia, bay of islands, buggery, change, children, church, code, consent, crime, crown, culture, death, death penalty, denmark, europe, family, french, gay, government, grave, heterosexual, holland, homosexual, homosexual law reform, imprisonment, kissing, law, legislation, lgbt, love, marriage, missionary, other, people, prison, punishment, queen, recognition, records, rotorua, school, sex, sexuality, social, sodomy, speech, support, time, top, treaty, trust, unions, university, wellington, women, women's studies, work