Strange Masquerade (Evening Post, 26 September 1945)

A peculiar story emerged from Auckland on 26 September 1945 about a woman who lived for ten years masquerading as a man. The 30-year-old, described as tall and robust, had successfully passed herself off as male, even marrying an 18-year-old girl. The situation came to light when the Registrar-General in Wellington noticed a marriage certificate with a name linked to a woman previously rejected for military service in 1940 due to her true sex being revealed during a medical examination. Police inquiries followed, leading to an interview with the individual who was referred to as "Mr. X." During the conversation, "he" confessed to being a woman and explained the circumstances leading to the masquerade. The couple was employed in the same factory, and in their social circle, they were regarded as a conventional husband and wife. The marriage was witnessed only by their mothers, with only one being aware of Mr. X's real identity. The interview revealed Mr. X's indifference to the attention. He shared how his transition occurred during the mid-1930s after facing difficulties while living as a woman. He felt pressure to conform to an identity that did not align with his natural inclinations, which led to job losses. Desiring to succeed in a male-dominated workforce, he opted to live as a man. After many years of successfully maintaining this identity, Mr. X resisted disclosing the full details of his life to reporters, expressing concerns over how it would affect his job and personal relationships. Mr. X described his feelings of disappointment when, during a wartime ballot, he was rejected by military doctors after his mother revealed his sex. Despite this, he had developed a masculine persona, engaging in traditionally male activities such as boxing and swimming, and became adept in various sports. The event twisted societal norms; he and his young wife enjoyed their relationship and were content despite its unusual foundation. They had little in the way of traditional marriage rituals, having quickly returned to work after a brief visit to his mother for dinner post-wedding. Mr. X expressed frustration about society's perception of their relationship, insisting that their happiness was what mattered most. As the story gained traction, it raised significant questions about identity, gender roles, and societal acceptance in the post-war period, while highlighting the personal struggles of those who felt compelled to conform to societal expectations at the expense of their true selves.

The text on this page is created, in the most part, using Generative AI and so may contain errors or omissions. It is supplied to you without guarantee or warranty of correctness. If you find an error or would like to make a content suggestion please get in contact

The text on this page is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-ShareAlike 3.0 New Zealand

relationships