Vatican A.I.D.S. Meeting Disrupted (Press, 15 November 1989)

On 15 November 1989, the Vatican City held its first conference dedicated to AIDS, which became a contentious platform highlighting the divide between religious moralism and the realities faced by those suffering from the disease. The conference started with significant disturbances, including the eviction of an Irish priest suffering from AIDS, who was removed by security guards for displaying a banner declaring, "The Church has AIDS." Father John White spoke to reporters, expressing his frustration at the lack of representation for those living with the condition. The atmosphere at the conference was charged as scientists and AIDS victims confronted what they deemed outdated and insensitive viewpoints perpetuated by religious leaders. Peter Larkin, a 34-year-old patient from London involved with a support group called Catholic AIDS Link, vocally challenged remarks made by Monsignor Carlo Caffarra, a theologian aligned with Pope John Paul II. Caffarra's speech labelled homosexual activity as perverse and dismissed the moral justification for using condoms, even in efforts to prevent the transmission of AIDS. He further criticized government campaigns promoting condom use, alleging they fostered permissiveness and failed to consider the issue of personal responsibility in relation to risky behaviours. Larkin termed Caffarra's stance as "crazy" and "immoral," asserting that negligence towards safe sexual practices contributed to unnecessary suffering and death among those afflicted by AIDS. He argued that ignoring the sexual behaviour of individuals was tantamount to denying reality. As the conference continued, Robert Gallo, a key figure in the discovery of the AIDS virus, took issue with remarks made by Cardinal John O’Connor of New York, who had attributed the AIDS crisis to what he described as "dangerous life-styles." Cardinal O’Connor urged a return to what he considered more virtuous living, pointing to condoms and clean needles as misguided solutions. Gallo disagreed with the Cardinal’s characterization of these methods, suggesting that the focus should instead be on understanding the broader implications of behaviours associated with the spread of the disease. He pointed out that not everyone subscribes to beliefs that frame discussions around the afterlife. Highlighting the discontent among AIDS advocates, Robert Kunst, director of an AIDS centre in Miami, condemned the conference as a "sham," insisting that genuine discourse would involve the voices of those directly affected by AIDS. The event illuminated a profound disconnect between religious doctrine and the lived experiences of individuals battling AIDS, underscoring a critical need for more inclusive dialogues that reflect the challenges faced by patients and the effectiveness of public health strategies.

The text on this page is created, in the most part, using Generative AI and so may contain errors or omissions. It is supplied to you without guarantee or warranty of correctness. If you find an error or would like to make a content suggestion please get in contact

The text on this page is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-ShareAlike 3.0 New Zealand