Other Ailments Diagnosed As A.I.D.S. —... (Press, 30 April 1986)

A study by Dr Harry Hollander, the director of a clinic in San Francisco, revealed that a significant number of patients incorrectly diagnosed with A.I.D.S. actually suffered from other conditions. According to the research, published in the March 1986 issue of the "Western Journal of Medicine," approximately 10 per cent of 80 patients referred to the clinic had alternate ailments ranging from tuberculosis to heart disease. One particular case highlighted the grave consequences of such misdiagnoses; a patient died of untreated cancer because it was misidentified as A.I.D.S. Dr Hollander noted that the misdiagnosis rate in the San Francisco area could be higher than elsewhere in the country. He attributed this to a tendency among local doctors to overly emphasise A.I.D.S. when assessing patients, especially those within high-risk groups, such as homosexual men. He explained that this focus could lead to “pigeonholing” patients based on prevalent notions surrounding the disease. Many patients arrived at their physicians' offices already concerned about A.I.D.S., contributing to diagnostic errors. The study identified several cases where patients were misdiagnosed. For instance, a homosexual man of 33 was sent to the clinic for lymphadenopathy, a condition often associated with A.I.D.S. However, further examination revealed he was suffering from a specific type of tuberculosis impacting lymph nodes. Another case involved a 37-year-old patient who presented with chest pain and was misdiagnosed with A.I.D.S.-related pneumonia due to misinterpretation of an X-ray, while he actually had blocked arteries. A 20-year-old winery worker, who complained of fatigue and pain under his arm, was assumed to be homosexual based on his living situation and was sent to the clinic under false assumptions. After examination, he was found to have a muscle strain caused by lifting heavy boxes, and not a serious illness as suspected. Lastly, a 54-year-old man presenting symptoms like fever, chills, and cough was also misdiagnosed. His doctor initially believed he had A.I.D.S.-related pneumonia; however, further checks revealed Hodgkin’s disease, which tragically went untreated for four months due to poor diagnostic practices. Dr Hollander stressed the importance of adhering to stringent diagnostic criteria to prevent patients from being unnecessarily distressed by misdiagnoses and to ensure timely treatment for unrelated conditions.

The text on this page is created, in the most part, using Generative AI and so may contain errors or omissions. It is supplied to you without guarantee or warranty of correctness. If you find an error or would like to make a content suggestion please get in contact

The text on this page is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-ShareAlike 3.0 New Zealand