The Press Monday, June 17, 1985. Messages For The... (Press, 17 June 1985)

On 17 June 1985, an analysis of the recent Timaru by-election highlighted significant implications for New Zealand's political landscape. The Labour Party, despite its substantial majority in Parliament, faced a considerable defeat in Timaru, a seat it had held for 50 years. This outcome raised concerns about the government's support, particularly as it had been less than a year since Labour took office. The Labour Party's loss in Timaru was interpreted as a potential indicator of diminished public support for its policies, which were still in the early stages of implementation. While some party members anticipated a decrease in support during this midterm period, the scale of the defeat paved the way for speculation that Labour would have similarly struggled in a General Election. The government's failure to secure the electorate's backing pointed to a possible disconnect between their economic policies and public perception, suggesting that the anticipated benefits of these policies were not fully recognised by voters. Moreover, the analysis noted that the government’s communication strategy might have contributed to its electoral challenges. Despite advocating for "open government" and engaging in public discussions such as an economic summit and Budget clarifications, the Labour government's messaging seemed insufficient to counteract the discontent surrounding its proposals, particularly on issues like defence policy, superannuation, unionism, and social reforms. The Prime Minister, Mr Lange, had previously sought a concensus-driven approach; however, the result suggested that policies had instead prompted division among the populace. Candidate selection also played a pivotal role in the by-election outcome. While Labour's candidate, Jan Walker, had ties to Timaru, she lacked strong local roots, allowing the National Party's candidate, Maurice McTigue, who had local popularity, to gain the upper hand. This aspect highlighted challenges for Labour in connecting with South Island electorates, which had seen candidates from the North Island in previous selections. Moving forward, the Labour Party must demonstrate tangible benefits from its policies before the next General Election to regain confidence among voters. Conversely, the National Party’s victory bolstered Mr McLay's leadership and party morale. However, it raised questions about their long-term direction, especially given that former Labour voters appeared to have shifted allegiance to the New Zealand Party, which gained notable traction in Timaru. The Timaru result should caution both parties against complacency. For Labour, the loss serves as a reminder of the need for effective communication and visible policy benefits to maintain support. For National, while the victory was significant, they must consider strategies to win back voters who have aligned with the New Zealand Party to enhance their prospects in future elections. The large turnout at the by-election indicated that voters were engaged and serious about their choices, reinforcing that this result was more than a mere temporary shift in sentiment.

The text on this page is created, in the most part, using Generative AI and so may contain errors or omissions. It is supplied to you without guarantee or warranty of correctness. If you find an error or would like to make a content suggestion please get in contact

The text on this page is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-ShareAlike 3.0 New Zealand