Deferred Sentence For Stabbing (Press, 25 August 1983)

On 25 August 1983, a transsexual named Sybil Jane Damon, also known as Desmond Wayne MacDonald, was given a deferred sentence for three years after she was found guilty of stabbing a woman, Gina Parata, three times during a violent altercation in a flat on Peterborough Street. The incident occurred on 22 February 1983 when a group described as a "pack of angry, drunken jackals" invaded the flat, leading to a fight over furniture left by a previous tenant. Damon, aged 30 and working at a hamburger bar, admitted to being a transsexual as assessed by her psychiatrist. Her boyfriend, 29-year-old Gordon Andrew Billings, who was sentenced to four months of non-residential periodic detention, was found guilty of suppressing evidence by washing Damon’s fingerprints from the knife used in the stabbing. Billings had been trying to seek police assistance when the incident occurred and had previously attempted to mediate during the impending conflict. During sentencing, Mr Justice Cook acknowledged that Damon's violent act was not premeditated and stemmed from the chaotic situation caused by the group that invaded their flat. The court heard that Damon had requested police help before the stabbing took place, and the injuries inflicted on Parata resulted in no permanent disability. The probation reports on both individuals were compassionate, highlighting that Damon had not been convicted of a violent crime in over five years and had significantly changed her life, overcoming substance addictions. Damon's relationship with Billings was portrayed as stable and supportive, allowing both to improve their lives. Mr Justice Cook ultimately decided against a custodial sentence for Damon, recognising the complexities of her situation given her gender transition and the disturbing circumstances surrounding the altercation. He expressed concern that sending her to prison could undermine her progress and emotional stability. Regarding Billings, the judge acknowledged that while he suppressed evidence, the act was not severe enough to warrant harsh punishment, given his role as a protector of Damon. While he emphasised the seriousness of interfering with police investigations, Cook considered the context of Billings' actions, noting the close relationship with Damon and the absence of his direct involvement in the initial fight. Thus, on this day in court, Damon received a deferred sentence, reflecting the complexities of her case and the societal challenges faced due to her gender identity, while Billings faced a lesser sentence for his actions in support of her.

The text on this page is created, in the most part, using Generative AI and so may contain errors or omissions. It is supplied to you without guarantee or warranty of correctness. If you find an error or would like to make a content suggestion please get in contact

The text on this page is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-ShareAlike 3.0 New Zealand