Bodyguard’s Resignation Renews ‘gay’ Row (Press, 12 August 1982)

The resignation of Michael Trestrail, a former police commander and Queen Elizabeth's bodyguard, due to a scandal involving a homosexual affair has reignited debates in Britain regarding the role of homosexuals in prominent positions. Trestrail's resignation followed revelations that a former partner attempted to sell his story to the tabloid "The Sun." This situation raised concerns about potential blackmail that could threaten the safety of the Queen and national security. Prominent figures in British politics weighed in on the controversy. Leo Abse, a key proponent of the 1967 legislation that decriminalised homosexual acts between consenting adults, condemned the media's treatment of Trestrail, likening it to a modern form of public shaming. Sir David Napley, Trestrail’s solicitor, urged the press to exercise more fairness and cease their scrutiny of his client. In contrast, some newspapers expressed apprehension regarding Trestrail's suitability as a bodyguard, suggesting that emotional instability in homosexual relationships could pose risks. The right-leaning "Daily Express" argued that homosexuals could still be loyal officers but warned about the emotional vulnerability associated with perceived infidelity, thus neglecting the larger issue of societal prejudice against homosexuals in security roles. The case has instilled fear among homosexuals in public services, with advocates suggesting it highlights the ongoing discrimination and challenges faced by gay individuals. Andrew Lumsden from "Gay News" noted the case could deter many from being open about their sexuality. John Ward from the Civil Servants' Association expressed concerns that heightened scrutiny could lead to a witch-hunt that would force homosexuals to conceal their identities, potentially leading to greater vulnerability to blackmail. Historically, concerns about homosexuals being security risks stem from Cold War incidents involving spies like Guy Burgess and Donald Maclean. However, only one notable case—John Vassal—was definitively linked to blackmail due to homosexuality. Although a recent government report indicated that there should be no blanket exclusion of homosexuals from sensitive civil service positions, actual practice may not reflect this, as many gay civil servants confront inconsistent guidelines and fear repercussions for disclosing their sexuality. Legal reforms have been slow, with male homosexuality remaining illegal in Northern Ireland until recently, while military service remains closed to homosexuals. Efforts to reform legal frameworks around inheritance and housing rights for gay individuals have stagnated, with some decisions reinforcing the potential for workplace discrimination. Despite a gradual shift in public opinion—evidenced by an increase in acceptance of homosexuality over the years—significant barriers remain. The opposition Labour Party is advocating for legislation against sexual discrimination, symbolising the long road ahead for full acceptance and rights for the LGBTQ+ community in Britain.

The text on this page is created, in the most part, using Generative AI and so may contain errors or omissions. It is supplied to you without guarantee or warranty of correctness. If you find an error or would like to make a content suggestion please get in contact

The text on this page is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-ShareAlike 3.0 New Zealand