Condescending Commercials (Press, 4 August 1980)

On 4 August 1980, the discussion surrounding the depiction of women in advertising took centre stage, highlighting the traditional gender roles often portrayed in media. This conversation was sparked by an experiment conducted by Sam Rothenstein, a female director at the advertising firm D’Arcy MacManus and Masius, who tested two contrasting commercials with a group of women. One advert depicted a classic image of a happy mother in a flowery apron, dutifully preparing breakfast for her family, while the other showed a more contemporary scene where the same mother, dressed in a fur coat, was involved in a shared breakfast experience with her children and husband before they all left together. The response from the participants was overwhelmingly emotional, revealing deep-seated frustrations over being relegated to roles as supportive figures solely catering to men, rather than being portrayed in a more empowering light. Many women expressed their resentment at the consistent portrayal of women as either sweet housewives or alluring figures, solely existing to please others. Alongside the experimental films, a meeting was held in London to commemorate a decade of Britain’s Women in Media group, dedicated to combating the sexism prevalent in advertisements and media representations of women. Notable speakers included actress Jane Lapotaire, news announcer Anna Ford, and journalist Bel Mooney, who shared their experiences and advocated for change. The meeting yielded a spirited debate over the kind of images that should replace old stereotypes. While some participants proposed a more realistic portrayal of women's lives and occupations, highlighting their roles in various service industries, others argued that media often sells dreams rather than reality. The discussion acknowledged the challenge of marketing products effectively; showing unglamorous representations could hinder sales. Ford advocated for utilising humour to challenge stereotypes, referencing a successful American poster promoting a bank clerk with the catchphrase, "Hire him, he’s got great legs." This approach suggests that clever marketing could reshape public perceptions without relying on existing clichés. More broadly, the conversation underscored the tension between realism and the aspirational nature of advertising. While the ideal might be to represent women authentically, the nature of advertising often leans towards enhancing fantasies rather than relaying the everyday experiences of women. As the meeting drew to a close, it became evident that while the women’s perspectives on advertising were varied, a collective yearning for more nuanced, realistic portrayals remained central to their discussions. They sought representations that reflect the diverse realities of women's lives, ambitions, and contributions, rather than confining them to outdated stereotypes that no longer resonate with a significant portion of the female population. The overarching sentiment was a call for change, to move beyond simply selling dreams to portraying the rich tapestries of women’s true experiences, even as the complexities of marketing continued to challenge this goal.

The text on this page is created, in the most part, using Generative AI and so may contain errors or omissions. It is supplied to you without guarantee or warranty of correctness. If you find an error or would like to make a content suggestion please get in contact

The text on this page is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-ShareAlike 3.0 New Zealand