Home and People (Press, 4 April 1978)

An article by Polly Toynbee from the “Guardian” published on 4 April 1978 raises significant questions about societal perceptions of lesbian mothers and their suitability as parents. Toynbee critiques the discrimination faced by lesbian mothers in custody battles, highlighting the arbitrary and often absurd conditions set by judges, such as prohibiting signs of affection between a couple while children are around, which reflect deep-seated prejudice rather than legitimate concerns for child welfare. The article discusses the harmful stereotypes that associate lesbians with hypersexuality and child molestation, which have no basis in reality, as there are no documented cases of lesbian child molestation. Toynbee points out that while male homosexuals can achieve mainstream acceptance, lesbians remain stigmatized and viewed through a lens of suspicion and negativity. Through the testimonies of several lesbian mothers, the piece illustrates the struggles they face in gaining custody or access to their children. One mother, Laura, describes how her lesbianism was used against her in court, resulting in a lengthy custody battle and fear of losing access to her children. Another mother, Wendy, shares her perspective on raising her son with the practical involvement of a male friend, stating that their family structure is functionally equivalent to other family types. Others, like Mary, have faced complete denial of access to their children, with judges expressing overt bias. The article highlights the inconsistency in court rulings and the lack of understanding from authority figures regarding lesbian parenting. Toynbee argues for a reevaluation of societal assumptions regarding parenthood, questioning what qualifies someone to be deemed a responsible parent and highlighting the arbitrary nature of such judgments. She challenges the notion that lesbians are any less qualified than heterosexual parents who may be ignorant or abusive. The ongoing prejudice faced by lesbian mothers persists even in legal contexts, as noted by barrister Judith Walker, who reports that victories in custody cases are rare due to entrenched biases in magistrates' courts and even amongst High Court judges. The article concludes with mentions of ongoing research into lesbian parenting being conducted at the Institute of Psychiatry, suggesting that the early findings indicate no harmful effects on children raised in lesbian households. This research aims to provide empirical evidence against the biases that penetrate custody decisions, reinforcing the idea that a loving, supportive environment is paramount in child-rearing, regardless of the parents' sexual orientation.

The text on this page is created, in the most part, using Generative AI and so may contain errors or omissions. It is supplied to you without guarantee or warranty of correctness. If you find an error or would like to make a content suggestion please get in contact

The text on this page is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-ShareAlike 3.0 New Zealand