Radio Review A Camp Divided (Press, 12 July 1975)

On 12 July 1975, journalist Marcia Russell expressed her views on radio regarding the role of members of Parliament in upholding national morals, particularly in relation to ongoing debates about a homosexual law reform. The discussions in Parliament attracted limited media coverage, likely due to being held on a Friday, a day when news outlets are often preoccupied. The political discourse was noted for its civil tone, yet it highlighted controversial perspectives. Several MPs spoke against the reform, with Sir John Marshall describing homosexuality as "loathsome." Interestingly, many opposed to the measure acknowledged the existence of homosexuals, describing this orientation as "unnatural," while simultaneously advocating for these individuals to keep their identities private. During the debates, the rationale offered for opposing the bill included claims of minimal prosecution and harassment of homosexuals by police. This was contested by the Probation Officers’ Association, which pointed out that homosexuals were indeed facing legal consequences for their sexual orientation. An odd argument arose when an MP questioned why the police and military were exempted from the reform, subsequently praising these institutions as paragons of morality. While the proceedings were not broadcasted by one local station, listeners expressed concern over the quality of radio journalism. Specific critiques were aimed at announcers and local news-readers, with one popular figure, Jessica Weddell, being accused of lacking objectivity in presenting news. Despite previously being a respected figure in broadcasting, her current approach was questioned by listeners. In contrast, veteran newsreader Bill Toft was praised for his impartiality and professionalism. Listeners were also reacting positively to "Serials, Soap Operas, and Ill Stars," a radio programme that reportedly garnered significant audience appreciation. It was claimed that radio stimulates imagination more than television, as evidenced in various broadcasts. The "Broadcasts to Schools" initiative was highlighted, revealing that a substantial percentage of educators utilised this educational service, which summarised current events in a comprehensible manner for students. Despite some elements of the programmes being critiqued, the overall contribution to education was acknowledged. A fictional serial titled "Smith's Dream," aired on Tuesday afternoons, was reviewed unfavourably for its adaptation of a C. K. Stead novel. Set in a New Zealand governed by a fascist regime—a narrative which prompts reflection on society and individual roles—the serial struggled to impress critics. In a lighter moment, David Inglis of Radio New Zealand Parliamentary shared gossip suggesting that National MP Logan Sloane accused him and a colleague of being Labour supporters. He implied that another MP was the true source of this allegation, hinting at underlying political tensions and dynamics within Parliament. This incident provided insight into the often tumultuous relationships and rivalries within New Zealand's political landscape in 1975.

The text on this page is created, in the most part, using Generative AI and so may contain errors or omissions. It is supplied to you without guarantee or warranty of correctness. If you find an error or would like to make a content suggestion please get in contact

The text on this page is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-ShareAlike 3.0 New Zealand