Seeking Another Gender (Press, 27 July 1974)

In her book "Conundrum," Jan Morris reflects on her personal journey of gender transition, addressing the complexities faced by individuals born male who identify as female. Morris, born James Morris, recounts her experiences and the long process of reconciling her internal identity with her physical existence, ultimately culminating in gender reassignment surgery. The book challenges conventional understandings of gender and sexuality but has drawn criticism for its lack of depth regarding the experiences of transgender individuals. Critics have pointed out that many readers may feel uncomfortable with Morris's presentation of male and female identities, with some men feeling their masculinity is unfairly critiqued and some women believing their femininity is superficially elevated. The book has been described as vague, failing to provide concrete depictions of life as a transgender person and instead relying on impressions and hints that leave readers guessing about essential experiences. Morris herself acknowledges the challenges of revisiting her past, which perhaps contributes to the book's evasiveness. While she presents her evolving identity in a moving manner, Morris appears to gloss over many of the struggles and miseries associated with her experience, instead focusing on moments of happiness which seem disproportionate in light of her past difficulties. Her discussion of sexuality is particularly controversial; Morris advocates a kind of pan-sexualism that dismisses traditional sexual relationships, suggesting that she found erotic pleasure in art and nature rather than in interpersonal connections. This approach raises concerns among readers, who may find it undermines the significance of sexual identity and relationships. Morris draws a dichotomy between male and female qualities, claiming her transition was motivated by a spiritual quest for gentleness and sensitivity. However, this raises questions about the necessity of a physical transformation if the quest was primarily spiritual. Morris argues for an inherent biological distinction between the sexes, claiming she experiences emotions in a way that James, as a male, did not. Some readers suggest that James's adherence to societal expectations of masculinity may have shaped his experiences more than an innate difference in identity. The book ultimately presents Morris’s newfound peace as stemming from her achievement of self-acceptance and identity clarity, rather than her status as a woman. Critics posit that if Morris had recognised the universal quest for identity that her experience represents, she might have crafted a more insightful exploration of her journey. Instead, the work remains a deeply personal account that may lack broader relevance in discussions about gender identity and roles. Nonetheless, her narrative reflects the struggles faced by those grappling with gender dysphoria and the search for personal truth, albeit in a manner that some feel obscures the realities of this human condition.

The text on this page is created, in the most part, using Generative AI and so may contain errors or omissions. It is supplied to you without guarantee or warranty of correctness. If you find an error or would like to make a content suggestion please get in contact

The text on this page is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-ShareAlike 3.0 New Zealand