Allegations Of Irregularities At Cherry Farm... (Press, 21 November 1963)

A report released on 21 November 1963 by Mr W. H. Reid, the district inspector of mental hospitals for Otago, concluded that allegations of misconduct at Cherry Farm Hospital were baseless. The inquiry, prompted by anonymous claims published in a weekly paper, investigated accusations of victimisation, homosexuality, and improper conduct by staff members. Health Minister Mr McKay highlighted that the allegations were completely unfounded. Mr Reid's findings addressed several specific allegations. He determined that claims of homosexual conduct by a charge nurse, referred to as X, had "no substance." He also evaluated seven other allegations which could imply impropriety but found none had merit. An investigation into claims of favouritism by X revealed that while he did give gifts to certain patients, such actions could create jealousy among those who did not receive gifts, leading to unnecessary complications within the hospital environment. In evaluating complaints against other members of the staff, Mr Reid again found no evidence to support any further allegations. He also investigated a patient's complaint regarding treatment and found that the patient's condition was largely due to his own lack of cooperation with hospital protocols. Addressing the issue of victimisation, Mr Reid indicated that complaints from staff regarding unfair treatment were more reflective of their resistance to criticism rather than genuine victimisation. He examined eight complaints of victimisation and concluded that these were not substantiated. Furthermore, during the inquiry, 11 specific complaints concerning general hospital administration were examined, out of which only two came from relatives, signalling a general satisfaction with the treatment being provided at Cherry Farm. Most patients were reported to receive appropriate and effective treatment. Mr Reid noted that the hospital had been under significant strain, suggesting that the inquiry had disrupted its administration and might have negatively impacted patient care. He acknowledged that only minor complaints were substantiated and attributed the high standard of patient care to the overall efficiency of the hospital. He also commented on the importance of following proper communication channels within the hospital and stressed that breaches of confidentiality by staff members who spoke to the media about hospital matters were inappropriate. In conclusion, Mr Reid affirmed the dedication of staff members like charge nurse X, appreciating their emotional engagement with patients while asserting that there was nothing "sinister" in their actions. The report suggested that claims of severe misconduct were unfounded and reflected a need for better internal communication to address grievances appropriately.

The text on this page is created, in the most part, using Generative AI and so may contain errors or omissions. It is supplied to you without guarantee or warranty of correctness. If you find an error or would like to make a content suggestion please get in contact

The text on this page is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-ShareAlike 3.0 New Zealand