Nurse Denies Indecency Charges (Press, 17 August 1963)

On 16 August 1963, a significant inquiry was held regarding allegations against a Charge Nurse, referred to as “X”, at Cherry Farm Hospital in Dunedin. The inquiry, led by Mr W H Reid, the strict inspector under the Mental Health Act, focused on claims of indecency and improper conduct towards patients. Various counsel represented different parties during the proceedings, while Mr Reid mandated that the identities of witnesses remain confidential, employing letters for their identification. During the inquiry, Charge Nurse “X” emphatically denied all allegations of indecency and favouritism. Mr M Joel, representing “X”, asserted that the charges were completely unfounded and described them as a “farrago of distortion” motivated by envy and malice. It was acknowledged that “X” had made some errors in medication over the years, but Joel dismissed the allegations as an unjust attempt to harm his reputation and well-being. “X” testified that he had started his nursing career in 1947 and had become a charge nurse by 1957. When questioned about the allegations, “X” categorically denied having any intentions or actions that could be deemed indecent. He called the claims made by the patients and staff as “fabrications” and expressed his confusion regarding their motivations. In his defence, “X” mentioned that he had occasionally provided gifts to patients, which he deemed necessary items and clothing that the hospital did not supply, purchased with his own funds. He also defended the practice of patients visiting him at Seacliff Hospital, asserting that such visits had received approval. In response to questions about his emotional involvement with patients, “X” denied any inappropriate behaviour, including claims of kissing or fondling. He acknowledged that, with medical permission, he had brought three patients to his home for tasks, countering any suggestions of inappropriate conduct. Support for “X” was also presented through testimonies, with a staff doctor stating that he was among the most reliable nurses at the hospital, always treating patients fairly and maintaining excellent moral conduct. The inquiry is set to continue, with further sessions scheduled for the following week.

The text on this page is created, in the most part, using Generative AI and so may contain errors or omissions. It is supplied to you without guarantee or warranty of correctness. If you find an error or would like to make a content suggestion please get in contact

The text on this page is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-ShareAlike 3.0 New Zealand