Murder Charge (Press, 26 August 1954)

The trial of Pauline Yvonne Parker, aged 16, and Juliet Marion Hulme, aged 15, on charges of murdering Honora Mary Parker, the mother of Pauline, resumed with the cross-examination of the defence's first witness, Dr. R. W. Medlicott. Dr. Medlicott had spent over seven hours in the witness box, discussing the mental condition of the accused girls, with some of his testimony focusing on their diaries, which illustrated their unusual thought patterns and relationships. The trial, now in its third day, has drawn significant public interest, with many spectators eager to catch a glimpse of the accused. Dr. Medlicott reflected on entries from Parker's diary, which revealed hints of a delusional belief in their own intellectual superiority and a "fourth world." He described the girls as displaying signs of paranoia, suggesting they were living within a delusional framework. He noted that they expressed beliefs inconsistent with reality, such as feeling they possessed an additional part of the brain that allowed them to perceive a spiritual paradise. Dr. Medlicott highlighted a disturbing pattern in the diaries, where the tone shifted from ordinary adolescent themes to more violent and dark content, particularly in the lead-up to the murder. He described how entries showed signs of extreme excitement, a disregard for societal norms, and an increasing obsession with the notion of killing Parker. He concluded that by June 1954, both girls were grossly insane, unable to appreciate the moral implications of their actions. The prosecution, represented by Mr. A. W. Brown, challenged Dr. Medlicott's conclusions, questioning the medical basis of his claims of insanity and whether the girls truly lacked an understanding of their actions. Dr. Medlicott maintained that the girls' mental state at the time of the crime indicated systemic delusional insanity, arguing that although they might have understood the legal implications of murder, they did not grasp its moral weight. The trial's proceedings underscored their complex emotional dynamics, showcasing a friendship that appeared to foster an environment conducive to shared delusions and a sense of invulnerability. As the trial continues, the court examines the balance between the girls' mental state and their criminal responsibility, with Dr. Medlicott’s extensive testimony poised to play a crucial role in determining the outcome of the case.

The text on this page is created, in the most part, using Generative AI and so may contain errors or omissions. It is supplied to you without guarantee or warranty of correctness. If you find an error or would like to make a content suggestion please get in contact

The text on this page is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-ShareAlike 3.0 New Zealand