C. E. Mackay Sentenced. (Press, 29 May 1920)

On 29 May 1920, Charles Evan Mackay was sentenced to fifteen years of imprisonment for attempted murder at the Supreme Court in Wanganui. Mackay had pleaded guilty to the charge, and his counsel, Mr Treadwell, explained that this decision was made after considerable reflection and responsibility was assumed by him and his colleague, Mr McEeth. Treadwell made it clear that there was no blame to be assigned to another individual, Cresswell, involved in the incident, asserting that Cresswell should be commended for his character and actions. In his address, Treadwell highlighted Mackay's distinguished background, describing him as a person of considerable academic achievement, a member of a respected profession, and a previous holder of a prominent position in the community. This stark contrast between Mackay's prior status and his current predicament was noted as significant. Treadwell suggested that the root cause of Mackay's actions could be attributed to his long-standing struggles with homosexual monomania, which had led to considerable mental strain, particularly exacerbated by the fear of exposure. The court was informed that Mackay had taken steps to seek help from medical professionals and metaphysicians to address his mental health issues. Treadwell portrayed his client as having acted impulsively during a moment of distress, influenced by ongoing mental health difficulties. Justice Sir Robert Stout addressed Mackay directly, expressing sorrow over his situation. He had known Mackay and his family for many years and acknowledged Mackay's past academic brilliance and successful career. However, Justice Stout emphasized the importance of the sanctity of human life, indicating that any attack on life must be taken seriously. He reflected on the community's need to uphold justice to ensure safety and order. Ultimately, Sir Robert Stout expressed hope that Mackay could redeem himself, considering his guilty plea a positive step toward rehabilitation. Nonetheless, he imposed a sentence of fifteen years with hard labour, underscoring the serious nature of the crime and the necessity of justice.

The text on this page is created, in the most part, using Generative AI and so may contain errors or omissions. It is supplied to you without guarantee or warranty of correctness. If you find an error or would like to make a content suggestion please get in contact

The text on this page is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-ShareAlike 3.0 New Zealand