Second reading of the Bill

The audio from the second reading of the Marriage (Definition of Marriage) Amendment Bill captures a critical moment in New Zealand's legislative history. Recorded on March 13, 2013, at the Parliament buildings in Wellington, the audio features various parliament members discussing the bill that sought to redefine marriage, expanding it to embrace all eligible couples regardless of their sex, sexual orientation, or gender identity. Introduced to Parliament by Labour MP Louisa Wall, the bill was subject to a heated debate reflected in the polarity of views expressed over 1 hour and 46 minutes.

The bill aimed to promote equality, combat discrimination, and uphold the social value and legal status of all long-term relationships. Those in favor argued it was a matter of human rights and civil justice, while opponents often cited religious beliefs and the traditional definition of marriage as a union exclusively between a man and a woman. Some saw it as an unnecessary measure since civil unions already provided similar recognition, questioning the need to alter the traditional concept of marriage.

Throughout the proceedings, various parliament members took to the floor to explain their positions. The discourse was notable for its mostly respectful tone, despite the deeply polarizing nature of the issue. Many MPs highlighted personal stories, reflecting the impact of the debate on individuals and communities. Some argued for the bill's passage to ensure that all citizens are treated equally under the law and that love and commitment are recognized regardless of one's sexual orientation. Others felt changing the definition of marriage was unwarranted and that other legal remedies could ensure equality without altering marriage.

A significant portion of the debate also focused on the tension between religious freedoms and civil rights. There was acknowledgment that the bill, while predominantly addressing civil marriage, needed to respect religious beliefs and doctrines, which was reflected in the Select Committee's recommendation to amend Section 29 of the Marriage Act. This amendment intended to reassure religious organizations that they would not be compelled to marry same-sex couples against their beliefs.

The bill in question passed its second reading with 77 ayes and 44 noes, reflecting a society slowly gravitating toward inclusivity and acceptance.

This summary is created using Generative AI. Although it is based on the recording's transcription, it may contain errors or omissions. Click here to learn more about how this summary was created.

Chester Borrows Chris Auchinvole Eric Roy Jan Logie Kanwaljit Singh Bakshi Kevin Hague Lianne Dalziel Louisa Wall Ross Robertson Ruth Dyson Tau Henare Tim Macindoe Trevor Mallard Winston Peters

2010s, aotearoa new zealand, chester borrows, chris auchinvole, church, civil rights, civil union act (2004), civil unions, community, discrimination, equality, eric roy, family, government, graham capill, green party, homosexual law reform, human rights, human rights act (1993), identity, jan logie, kanwaljit singh bakshi, kevin hague, lianne dalziel, louisa wall, marriage, marriage amendment act (2012), marriage equality, national party, new zealand first, new zealand labour party, parliament buildings, parliament tv, religion, ross robertson, ruth dyson, social justice, tau henare, tim macindoe, trevor mallard, wellington, winston peters, youth

1990s, acceptance, access, adoption, advice, advocate, agenda, anxiety, apartheid, apathy, attitude, australia, beating, belief, belonging, bible, bird, bisexual, bullying, capital, career, celebrant, celebration, change, children, choice, christianity, circle of friends memorial, class, code, collective, coming out, compassion, competition, compromise, conscience vote, conservative, convictions, council, courage, crime, culture, dance, david, death, declaration, democracy, depression, desire, difference, disadvantage, division, divorce, entitlement, ethnicity, events, exclusive brethren, exercise, expectations, expression, face, faith, fear, film, fire, food, freedom, french, friends, frustration, future, gallery, gay, gender, gender identity, general election, god, grandchildren, grandparents, grave, grief, guilt, hamilton, happiness, hate, health, heritage, heterosexual, history, hit, homosexual, hope, horse, humanity, individual, integrity, isolation, job, joe, john banks, journey, justice, knowledge, language, law, leadership, legacy, legislation, lesbian, lgbt, listening, lobbying, london, love, lyrics, march, margaret mayman, marriage equality, meetings, member of parliament, michael moore, minority, misinformation, nature, normal, normal jones, opportunity, other, pain, parents, parties, partnership, passing, paul hutchison, peace, people, perception, persecution, plan, podcast, policy, power, prejudice, presbyterian, privilege, public opinion, queer, race, reading, recognition, referendum, relationships, respect, sad, school, select committee, self harm, sex, sexual orientation, sexuality, shame, siblings, social, social change, space, speech, spirituality, straight, strength, struggle, stuff, submission, suicide, support, television, the other side, time, top, touch, tradition, trans, transgender, treat, trust, truth, understanding, unions, uniqueness, values, voice, vote, wedding, wellington high school, west coast, wills, witness, women, work, worship