Committee of the Whole House

On March 26, 1986, a vital parliamentary debate unfolded in Wellington, New Zealand, focused on the Homosexual Law Reform Bill. Key members of Parliament, including Bill Sutton, Fran Wilde, Geoff Braybrooke, and others, vocalized their positions, illustrating a nation at a pivotal crossroads in its legislative history regarding human rights and equality. The discourse addressed various perspectives on whether to decriminalize sexual acts between consenting individuals of the same sex.

The primary contention lay in determining the age of consent. One side, aligned with Fran Wilde, the bill's proponent, argued for equal treatment under the law and the elimination of discrimination based on sexual orientation. They insisted that criminalizing consensual sexual acts between adults in private does not align with advancing a fair and equitable society. They argued that sexual orientation is established early in life and that legislation should not target people based on their sexual preferences.

In stark contrast, opponents of the bill, like John Banks, vehemently objected, calling the legislation "evil" and a threat to societal morals and the family unit. Banks contended that a significant portion of the population disapproved of the bill, as evidenced by a petition signed by over 800,000 individuals rejecting the proposed law reform.

The deliberation stretched beyond the age of consent, with concerns about the potential creation of homosexual brothels and the notion that legalizing sodomy could lead to more significant societal shifts, including the legalization of other controversial activities.

Meanwhile, references to developments in international jurisdictions, such as the recent passage of anti-discrimination legislation in New York, provided additional context and sparked debate about the direction and implications of such legal reforms. The New York law had prompted strong responses, including a threat from Cardinal John O'Connor to close down Catholic institutions if unable to operate under the new law faithfully, thus showcasing the depth of the divide on such human rights issues.

This parliamentary sitting encapsulated a crucial moment in New Zealand's legislative history as it grappled with questions of legal rights, societal norms, and the balance between individual freedom and community morals. While the arguments presented were deeply passionate and often polarizing, the debate underscored New Zealand's engagement with fundamental human rights principles and the complexities of reflecting diverse public sentiment in lawmaking.

This summary is created using Generative AI. Although it is based on the recording's transcription, it may contain errors or omissions. Click here to learn more about how this summary was created.

Bill Sutton Fran Wilde Geoff Braybrooke Graeme Lee Ian McLean Jim Anderton John Banks Maurice McTigue Michael Cullen Roger McClay Russell Marshall Trevor Young Venn Young Whetu Tirikatene Sullivan

1980s, aotearoa new zealand, bill sutton, equality, fran wilde, geoff braybrooke, graeme lee, homosexual, homosexual law reform, homosexual law reform act (1986), homosexual law reform petition, human rights, ian mclean, jim anderton, john banks, law, maurice mctigue, michael cullen, new zealand defence force (nzdf), parliament buildings, politics, roger mcclay, russell marshall, trevor young, venn young, wellington, whetu tirikatene sullivan

abuse, acceptance, acting, actions, activities, advice, affection, age of consent, agenda, allies, amsterdam, animals, anti discrimination, archives, army, assault, attitude, australia, balance, bars, bear, belief, bigotry, blood, boat, brothels, camp, census, change, chicago, children, choice, christianity, class, code, community, consent, courts, crime, dance, data, democracy, difference, discrimination, education, embarrassment, emotional, empowerment, encouragement, environment, euthanasia, examination, exercise, family, fat, fear, fire, food, fraud, freedom, friends, gay, government, grave, growing up, guidance, guilt, gym, hamilton, harassment, hat, health, heterosexual, history, holland, homosexual law reform, hope, horse, imprisonment, indecent act, indecent assault, individual, ireland, job, justice, knowledge, leadership, legislation, lesbian, liberalism, listening, london, march, member of parliament, military, morality, murder, national party, nature, navy, nelson, new age, news, nigeria, north shore, opportunity, other, pacific, parents, passing, people, petition, police, policy, prayer, prejudice, prison, public health, public opinion, punishment, questioning, radio, reading, recognition, referendum, relationships, religion, research, respect, review, running, safety, sailor, salvation army, san francisco, saying no, scene, school, select committee, sex, sexual orientation, sexuality, shame, sin, sleep, social, social welfare, sodomy, speech, study, suffering, support, survey, teacher, teaching, telegrams, threats, time, touch, training, trauma, travel, truth, university, values, victim, video, violence, vote, walking, wind, women, work, youth