Committee of the Whole House

In this audio recording from the 20th of November 1985, a parliamentary debate unfolds in the Committee of the Whole House during the consideration of the Homosexual Law Reform Bill in Wellington, New Zealand. The recording captures the voices of various members of parliament, including Graeme Lee, Roger Maxwell, Trevor Young, Whetu Tirikatene Sullivan, and Winston Peters, discussing the controversial bill.

The dialogue in the recording points toward a deeply divisive atmosphere surrounding the reform bill at that time. A central point of contention during the debate is Clause Five of the bill, which involves the age of consent and its implications for society. The audio indicates there were strong opinions on whether the bill should allow for the legal recognition of same-sex relationships and protect the rights of individuals regardless of their sexual orientation—a radical idea for that era. The bill is also linked to concerns surrounding the epidemic of AIDS, with some believing that passing the legislation could exacerbate the health crisis.

There were references to massive petitions against the bill, suggesting significant public opposition, while contrasting perspectives pointed out that inquiries into the petition confirmed that the majority of its signatures were authentic. This fueled the argument of those who opposed the bill, claiming that the evidence against it was sound and not to be dismissed.

The discussions also tread into areas of public morality and social health issues, with particular focus on Clause Nine, which would make it unlawful to discriminate based on a person's sexual orientation. The recording exhibits an attempt to weigh the medical evidence and the social implications against each other.

The debate demonstrates how some members of Parliament believed that deeper inquiry was merited, suggesting the need for a royal commission to investigate further before passing any legislation. Some of those against the bill expressed the view that it would be particularly damaging to the youth and the indigenous Polynesian population. The arguments covered range from the bill's alignment with international human rights standards, the historical precedents of societal changes in response to similar legislation elsewhere, and the position of various factions within New Zealand's society at that time.

The tension between personal moral beliefs and the principles of law is evident throughout the recording, as speakers alternately advocated for understanding and acceptance versus rejection of the reform bill. The debate also hints at the broader international context of the 1980s, including the global fight against AIDS and evolving societal values regarding sexual orientation.

In an overarching sense, the session documented in this audio reveals the struggle within New Zealand's Parliament to navigate the moral, legal, and societal facets of the Homosexual Law Reform Bill, reflecting the complexity of decision-making in the legislative process during a period where societal norms on sexuality were undergoing significant reassessment.

This summary is created using Generative AI. Although it is based on the recording's transcription, it may contain errors or omissions. Click here to learn more about how this summary was created.

Graeme Lee Roger Maxwell Trevor Young Whetu Tirikatene Sullivan Winston Peters

1980s, aotearoa new zealand, equality, graeme lee, homosexual, homosexual law reform, homosexual law reform act (1986), homosexual law reform petition, human rights, law, parliament buildings, politics, roger maxwell, trevor young, wellington, whetu tirikatene sullivan, winston peters

abuse, acceptance, actions, activities, advice, advocate, age of consent, archives, attraction, authenticity, balance, bars, bible, boat, books, building, bus, career, change, children, choice, christchurch, civil rights, closet, clubs, code, comedy, community, compromise, conflict, consent, conservative, convictions, crown, dating, discrimination, division, eating, elders, epidemic, escape, events, extremist, face, failure, future, gambling, gay, gay liberation movement, gay task force, germany, god, government, gym, hamilton, health, history, homo, homosexual law reform, hope, individual, justice, lesbian, letter, liberation, listening, marriage, mary, mayor, meetings, melbourne, myth, māori, nature, nazi germany, new york city, news, nigeria, opportunity, other, pacific, paris, parties, people, petition, police, privilege, promiscuity, race, racism, reading, referendum, rejection, research, respect, royal commission, running, school, select committee, sex, sexual orientation, sexuality, social, sodomy, speech, study, support, surgeon, survey, the closet, time, travel, truth, understanding, unnatural, vice, vietnam, vote, water, whipped, work