Second reading debate

This summary outlines key elements of a 1985 recording from the New Zealand Parliament buildings in Wellington. The recording captures parts of the debate over the second reading of the Homosexual Law Reform Bill on October 16, 1985. It includes contributions from various Parliament members: Bruce Townshend, Helen Clark, Judy Keall, Noel Scott, Phil Goff, Philip Burdon, Rex Austin, and Trevor de Cleene. Despite their correct spelling, some names may appear incorrectly in the document.

The bill in question sought to decriminalize homosexual acts between consenting adults and address discrimination based on sexual orientation. The debate reflects a contentious period in New Zealand's social history, with arguments considering morality, human rights, and the impact of such a law on society.

Some speakers observed the possibility of a dynamic shift in society’s attitudes towards homosexuality if the bill passed, warning against promoting lifestyles contrary to Christian values and societal norms. Concerns centered on protecting the youth and upholding what was deemed as traditional family structures, with some advocating for a higher age of consent, emphasizing the varied maturity rates between genders.

Other members, however, argued for the bill’s passage. They emphasized the human rights perspective, asserting that individuals should not be criminalized for private, consensual acts. They pointed out the inconsistency of penalizing homosexual behavior while more dangerous heterosexual misconduct goes unchecked.

An essential side of the argument highlighted the historical criminalization and persecution of homosexuals, indicating a need to reform outdated laws. The bill was perceived as an opportunity to reflect the nation’s maturity and tolerance by removing criminal sanctions against homosexuality and ensuring protection against discrimination for all citizens.

The recording paints a picture of a deeply divided Parliament and society, grappling with the moral and legal implications of homosexual acts and the recognition of equal rights. The content underlines the significance of the bill, not only in legal terms but also as a societal acknowledgement of diversity in sexual orientation.

This summary is created using Generative AI. Although it is based on the recording's transcription, it may contain errors or omissions. Click here to learn more about how this summary was created.

Bruce Townshend Helen Clark Judy Keall Noel Scott Phil Goff Philip Burdon Rex Austin Trevor de Cleene

1980s, aotearoa new zealand, bruce townshend, equality, helen clark, homosexual, homosexual law reform, homosexual law reform act (1986), homosexual law reform petition, human rights, judy keall, law, lesbian and gay archives of new zealand (laganz), noel scott, parliament buildings, phil goff, philip burdon, politics, rex austin, trevor de cleene, wellington

1880s, 1890s, abortion, abuse, acceptance, access, accident, acting, actions, activities, adultery, advocate, affection, africa, age of consent, alcoholism, animals, anti discrimination, archives, assumptions, attitude, attraction, australia, bars, bear, belief, bible, bigotry, binary, bisexual, board, books, boundaries, breakdown, burnout, california, campaigns, capital, celibate, change, children, china, choice, church, civil liberties, classification, closet, common law, community, compassion, connect, consent, conservative, convictions, courage, courts, death, death penalty, demisexual, democracy, denmark, design, desire, difference, dignity, discrimination, distribution, division, divorce, education, emotional, employment, encouragement, english language, environment, exercise, expectations, experiment, exploitation, expression, face, faith, family, fashion, fear, film, florida, forum, france, freedom, french, friends, gay, germany, ghana, god, gods, government, hamilton, health, heritage, heterosexual, high heels, history, hit, homer, homosexual law reform, hope, housing, humanism, humanity, identity, imprisonment, in phase, individual, injustice, integrity, intolerance, iran, ireland, isolation, italy, job, justice, justice committee, knowledge, language, lawyer, leather, legislation, legs, lesbian, lifestyle, listening, london, love, mania, marriage, member of parliament, mental health, mental health foundation, mental illness, middle east, minority, molestation, morality, nature, nazi germany, netherlands, new south wales, news, normal, north shore, opportunity, oscar wilde, other, parties, passing, passion, people, persecution, petition, plague, police, pornography, poverty, pregnancy, prejudice, presbyterian, priorities, prison, privacy, privilege, procreation, promiscuity, protest, public health, public opinion, punitive law, questioning, race, reading, reflection, regions, relationships, religion, rent, research, respect, review, romania, rugby, rural, sad, san francisco, school, select committee, self image, sex, sexology, sexual development, sexual orientation, sexuality, sin, social, social attitudes, socialism, sodomy, soliciting, south africa, spain, speech, squash, statistics, struggle, study, submission, suicide, support, survival, survivor, sweden, teaching, tension, the other side, threats, time, tolerance, trauma, truth, understanding, uniform, united kingdom, university, urban, values, victim, violence, vote, wales, women, work, writing