Audio from the session: Imperialism, Nationalism and Queer Liberation.
Western discourse often uses gay rights, women's rights, and gender politics to justify imperialism (for example justifying intervention in Afghanistan and Iraq). In this narrative Westerners must act 'for' queers, women, and other oppressed groups in the majority world. However liberation can only come through struggles by the oppressed for self-determination. A discussion of how to combine anti-imperialist politics with queer politics.
Summary
This summary outlines the content of an audio recording titled "Session 13 - Beyond conference," held at Wellington High School in Wellington, New Zealand on October 13, 2013. The session themed "Imperialism, Nationalism and Queer Liberation," features discussions concerning queer politics and liberation, intersectionality, and challenges faced by the queer community, specifically in the context of imperialism and nationalism. The duration of the audio is approximately 1 hour and 19 minutes and includes the perspectives of activists Ali Nissenbaum, Nadie Abu-Shanab, and Sara Fraser.
The panel begins with an analysis of queer oppression and the imperialist worldview that categorizes nations into oppressors and the oppressed based on their stance on queer rights. The talk emphasizes the inherent flaws in rallying for solidarity with queer communities globally without acknowledging the trans and homophobia within the so-called progressive nations. Indicating a binary setup where 'free' Western nations are contrasted against the oppressiveness of countries like Russia and Uganda, the discussion reflects on how this division is a distortion shaped by Orientalist perspectives.
The speakers bring attention to how traditional views of gender and sexual diversity have been eroded by colonialism and imperialism, particularly highlighting the class societies' imposition of strict gender binaries and family structures for protecting patriarchal inheritance. The historical exposition traces back to the emergence of this norm through religious doctrines in the Judaic-Christian tradition, colonial expansions, and eventual globalization of specific European gender and sexuality norms.
Ian Anderson points out that the fight against this colonizing imposition was fundamentally interconnected with struggles for cultural diversity, land rights, and broader liberation. The evolution of gay visibility politics is examined through the lens of past revolutions, noting how the rights and recognition gained were not uniformly extended to all members of the queer community, emphasizing lingering divisions.
Further, the talk shifts towards concepts like "homonationalism," the post-Cold War nurturance of queer identities contingent on structures of imperialist nationalism, and "homonormativity," a strive for recognition that often neglects queer individuals outside the monogamous, white, cisgendered paradigm. The discussion articulates how these dynamics play into sustaining the cultural dominance of imperialism by utilizing narratives that juxtapose Western progressiveness against the supposed conservativeness of the 'Orient.'
The panel also tackles the issue of pinkwashing, where states like Israel present themselves as LGBTQ+-friendly to distract from human rights violations and cultivate a progressive image globally. This form of marketing is critiqued, highlighting how it obscures the reality of oppression and attracts support from Western nations premised on misconstrued representations of Middle Eastern cultures.
Nadie Abu-Shanab introduces personal anecdotes reflecting on Middle Eastern women's resistance to both sexism and imperialism, urging for a nuanced understanding of these struggles and rejecting oversimplified narratives that position Western culture as a beacon for women's rights. The conversation culminates in a discussion around localized components of queer liberation, cautioning against adopting a one-size-fits-all Western-centric approach and acknowledging the diverse ways in which different communities strive for and conceptualize liberation.
The session, thus, concludes with a call to question prevailing assumptions, examine the complexity of intersecting identities, and actively dismantle the structures of power that utilize gender and sexual systems for justifying imperialist behavior. The panel advocates for grassroots strategies that incorporate voices from majority-world communities, attend to cultural and economic liberation, and foster global solidarity without perpetuating colonial legacies.
This summary is created using Generative AI. Although it is based on the recording's transcription, it may contain errors or omissions. Click here to learn more about how this summary was created.
Tags
2010s, abu ghraib, activism, ali nissenbaum, alqaws for sexual and gender diversity in palestinian society, aotearoa new zealand, beyond conference (2013), campaign for marriage equality, civil rights, civil unions, class, classism, colonisation, discrimination, dorian society, edward said, equality, family, gay liberation front, grant robertson, homonationalism, homonormativity, homophobia, human rights, ian anderson, imperialism, iran, iraq, israel, joan of arc, karl liebknecht, law, leslie feinberg, liberation, malala yousafzai, marriage equality, nadie abu-shanab, nationalism, new zealand defence force (nzdf), nigeria, olympic games, oppression, orientalism, palestine, palestinian queers for boycott divestment and sanctions, pink washing, politics, queer, queer liberation, rape, religion, russia, sarah schulman, sexual abuse, shakti community council, stonewall riots (1969), sylvia rivera, the persistent desire: a femme-butch reader, the queer avengers (wellington), torture, transgender warriors: making history from joan of arc to dennis rodman, transphobia, visibility, wellington, wellington high school
Tags (computer generated)
2000s, abuse, acceptance, acting, activities, agenda, apartheid, asian, assumptions, auckland, australia, benefits, berlin, bigotry, binary, bisexual, blackmail, books, bottom, boycott, building, campaigns, capital, change, children, chinese, christianity, church, civil society, closet, code, collaboration, colonialism, coming out, community, conference, conflict, connections, consensual sex, consent, conservative, conversation, council, culture, dating, death, death penalty, democracy, difference, discernment, diversity, division, dominant, economics, economy, education, embarrassment, energy, europe, exclusion, face, family violence, fantasy, farm, feminism, flags, food, forgiveness, forum, france, freedom, friends, future, gay, gender, gender binary, god, gods, gordon brown, heterosexual, history, hit, homer, homo, homosexual, homosexual law reform, homosexual law reform society, horse, identity, inequality, inheritance, internet, job, journey, judaism, justice, knowledge, ladies, lady gaga, language, lesbian, lgbt, london, loss, march, marketing, marriage, marriage equality, media, mental illness, middle class, middle east, migrants, military, minority, misogyny, music, muslims, narrative, nelson, normal, occupation, opportunity, other, pacific, parents, peace, people, perception, perversion, petition, pets, pink dollar, placard, plan, podcast, police, poverty, power, prejudice, prison, privacy, propaganda, proposition, psychology, queen, quiz, race, racism, rainbow, rally, reflection, refugee, relationships, representation, repression, research, resistance, revolution, runaway, security, sex, sexism, sexual identity, sexual liberation, sexual violence, sexuality, shoes, silence, skype, smoking, social, social media, solidarity, space, spaces, speech, stereotypes, strategy, strength, structure, struggle, stuff, success, support, tactics, teacher, the closet, the other side, ties, time, tolerance, top, tourism, tradition, trans, trans woman, transgender, treat, trust, truth, uganda, understanding, unions, university, urban, vancouver, video, violence, whitewash, women, women's rights, work, writing, yellow, youth