AI Chat Search Browse Media On This Day Map Quotations Timeline Research Free Datasets Remembered About Contact
☶ Go up a page

Parker and Hulme murder case [AI Text]

This page features computer generated text of the source audio. It may contain errors or omissions, so always listen back to the original media to confirm content. You can search the text using Ctrl-F, and you can also play the audio by clicking on a desired timestamp.

Hi, I'm Doctor Alison Laurie. I was the General Women's Studies Programme director at Victoria University of Wellington. Uh, here in New Zealand for many years, Uh, I'm a writer, oral historian, and he's been a gay activist. Today. I'm going to be looking at the Parker and Hume murder case of 1954. And the reason I'm going to be looking at that is because it's one of the first times that a discussion of lesbian [00:00:30] relationships, uh, takes place in the New Zealand media, and it takes place in a very negative context of murder, Uh, and of young girls out of control. And it has a big impact on how that generation of lesbians and their parents and their schools began to think about relationships between girls and women. Now, it's not the first time that lesbian relationships are mentioned [00:01:00] in the media. There's another case which happens in the thirties, which is the Freda Stark case, and the Mario uh, There's also been other mentions of women leading rebellious lives, especially women who have crossed, dressed, masqueraded as men, the famous case of Amy Bock and and other cases, too. But this case is one happening in the Postwar period, and it's been brought to great attention [00:01:30] because of film. Uh, was made about it, uh, after, uh, my colleague and I had published our book on it. Uh, and that's a film by Peter Jackson, Um, heavenly creatures and, uh, as well as that. There have been a lot of mentions in the media regularly as well as that, uh, one of the girls, Um, Juliet Hume. Uh, her identity was revealed after the [00:02:00] film was released. And, uh, she is Anne Perry, the crime writer. And she has now made a film of or appeared in a film where she's talked a bit about this case and other matters, too in relation, particularly to her writing. So what happens in this case is that, uh, Juliet Hume, who is the daughter of hire, and Henry Hume, [00:02:30] who come to New Zealand, though she is actually sent here first they come to New Zealand. He comes to take up the position as rector which today would be the vice chancellor of Canterbury University College, which today is, uh, Canterbury University. They were colleges at that time within the University of New Zealand and prior to. Then they had a professor taking the role of Rector, uh, and rotating it. It was then decided in the post war period [00:03:00] that they needed to have somebody doing that job full time. So Henry Hume applied for that job and came out here. He seemed to have very good qualifications. But as our research showed, actually, he his his career had been, uh, the opposite of what you might expect. He'd when other university scientists had gone to work for the government during the period of the war. That was when he'd been working in the university. He then went to work for the government when they [00:03:30] returned to university work. So his his career hadn't been as as as good as, perhaps might have been hoped when he got to Canterbury. He, uh he hadn't been there long before. The professors actually were not too pleased with the way he was turning out. He was quite arrogant. He didn't want to take their advice when he met on the university Senate and often voted against things that they wanted. For example, they wanted a school [00:04:00] of forestry established at at, uh at Canterbury, and he voted against that? Because in his opinion, um, it shouldn't be there. Hilda Hume, Uh, she was also not particularly popular. She founded the She was one of the founders of marriage guidance. And, uh, she was on the board of, uh, the, uh, Christchurch Girls High School. Uh, but she was the sort of woman who, uh, they called a man's woman. She was often quite dismissive [00:04:30] of other women and not a popular person, either. So they were very English people, very upper class English people in Christchurch, which was quite a small city at that time. And, uh, they weren't particularly popular. Uh, and then we have Pauline Parker. She was the daughter of, um, Herbert Reaper, who was a fishmonger, and Nora Parker, who, uh, was also a English migrant. And these [00:05:00] are both working class people. And Herbert had been previously married to a woman older than him. And he had two sons in that marriage. And he then ran off with, uh with and they went to Christchurch and pretended to be married and then had another family. And the other family were There were there were oddities about it. The first child was a blue baby and died in the 1st 24 hours after birth because of a blood condition. Then the next child was a normal [00:05:30] child. And then there's Pauline, who is a daughter but has a strange injury, which is never explained, uh, which gives her osteomyelitis of her leg. Uh, and she has that injury in the first two years of life, never properly explained how she got it. And then 10 years later they have another child down syndrome child called Rosemary, who's lives at home for a couple of years and then is an in in an institution. So these are two. They come from two very [00:06:00] different backgrounds. Pauline and Juliet. They meet at Christchurch Girls High School in 1953 and form a very close friendship, a friendship that's so close that it's remarked upon by the teachers. Um, it's considered, perhaps to be an unhealthy friendship, and the different class backgrounds of the two girls are quite significant in this regard that Pauline likes to go and stay with Juliet and, uh, what [00:06:30] basically is almost like a mansion, which was the residence of the rector, um, with extensive grounds. There at is these days. That's the University staff club. Um, and, uh, meanwhile, Pauline just lives over the fence from the high school in, uh, in a very modest home where her mother takes in Borders. And Pauline does a lot of housework in her diaries, which have [00:07:00] been depicted as terrible, terrible documents, but which in fact are full of very ordinary kinds of references, Uh, particularly to housework. And you wonder why she's doing so much past work until you realise that the mother takes in four Borders on full board and that this girl is the one that's being required to do all this kind of work so clearly it's not a very good home background. Clearly, there's a difficult relationship between Pauline and her mother. Then, um, the [00:07:30] Hume's marriage breaks up. Uh, Hilda Hume, uh, begins an affair with a man that she's counselled, um, Walter Perry and she actually moves him into the mansion. And, uh, this whole thing falls to pieces and they're going to divorce. So the Humes are leaving the country. In fact, the professors have by this stage, forced him Henry to resign because his it really hasn't worked out. This is by the stage. We're in 1954. His [00:08:00] appointment hasn't worked out and they want him to go. So he's been forced to resign. He's returning to England. Uh, the two Children, Juliet and her brother Jonathan, are going to be sailing off to South Africa, where they're going to be living with an aunt. And meanwhile, Hilda is going to going to be going off with Walter Perry. So that's what they're all doing. According to Pauline's diaries, there are various conversations that take place that she might be able to go with Juliet that somehow she could become [00:08:30] part of this family. It's pretty unrealistic. Then Pauline begins to see the big obstacle to her being able to be with Juliet as her mother. And so they she plans a murder. Uh, they take the mother. They take an AA Parker for a walk in the in, in Victoria Park and Christchurch, they batter Pauline batters who were the brick of stalking. Um, initially, there there is a number of statements that the two girls, uh, make, but but eventually [00:09:00] they both take responsibility for having participated in this. They're both charged with murder. The first degree they're both found guilty. They served five years in prison at Her Majesty's pleasure. They were released in 1959. Juliet leaves the country immediately and, uh goes to England. And, uh, Pauline is on probation for another five years, after which she also leaves they both are given new identities by the Justice Department. They're both given, uh, educational opportunities [00:09:30] in prison because there's a very liberal prison regime at that time and justice system which seeks to rehabilitate them. However, this crime is depicted whether or not they are actually having a lesbian relationship. Uh, and what we might mean by a lesbian relationship is unclear. But certainly it's the way that both the defence and the prosecution portray the relationship. The defence says they're crazy, and, uh, they are. They've got [00:10:00] a joint insanity known as one of the symptoms of this is lesbianism. Uh, when we interviewed the defence council, uh, Brian McClelland, he said, Well, the problem was they both confessed to it, and the only defence we had was insanity. But how could we find the two of them insane? And then this chap, Reginald Medico, comes along with this wonderful idea that they could have fully. So we went with that. So that's a cynical defence lawyer, uh, [00:10:30] using that kind of theory. So that was what was argued there. Meanwhile, the prosecution psychiatrist said, No, they're not mad. They're bad. They're dirty minded little girls was one of the quotes that they said the diaries were extensively quoted from from both sides to either prove that they were mad or that they were bad. Um, what isn't really considered is that this is a domestic murder. It comes out of what is clearly quite a dysfunctional household. It [00:11:00] comes out of what is clearly a very difficult relationship between Poly and her mother and that is not explored in the context of the court at all. Uh, it might well be the case that Juliet, in fact, blundered into somebody else's domestic murder, which might well have happened with or without her. She might in fact, not have participated as fully in this situation as she admit, as she confessed to having done, uh, in fact, maybe she should have been charged as an accessory after the fact. None of those [00:11:30] kinds of much more interesting legal questions, uh, have ever been raised in any, uh, discussions. Newspaper articles, uh, or and things about, uh, about this case, The Heavenly Creatures movie. Claims to be, uh, based on the diaries. It's largely a matter of Invention by Peter Jackson and, uh, his partner, Fran Walsh. Um, it's, uh, it's It's a it's a dramatisation, which, uh, Reginald Medley [00:12:00] Cott would particularly have liked because it depicts them a particularly poor lines, having fantasies, Plasticine figures that she sees moving around and none of that Is there any evidence whatsoever? For and in fact, the verdict of the court was that they were completely sane, which is why they found them guilty. They were lucky to be found guilty because had they been found insane, not guilty, they would have probably spent the rest of their lives incarcerated in a in a psychiatric hospital. And [00:12:30] probably at that time since, uh, uh, the psychiatric institutions were very keen to give our greatest novelist, Janet frame a prefrontal lobotomy, which she only escaped because she won a prize for literature. These two girls would probably have had would have been given that kind of surgery or lots of shock treatment. Anyway, it was much better for them in the prison system where an enlightened regime gave them the opportunities to continue their lives. So we will have to say that, [00:13:00] uh, most of most of what has been written about this case has been, uh, not not really very simplistic. Hasn't really looked at the more interesting aspects of it at all in our work. We were interested in the impact of the case, and we found that it had very negative effect on many, uh, girls. Many girls were became very frightened to have their relationships. Parents separated girls. Uh, in fact, one woman we talked [00:13:30] to her mother sent her to a psychiatrist. Uh, older lesbian couples, uh, were also affected by this, uh, people were very afraid that if they had a a lesbian relationship, perhaps that meant they were mad. Uh, it certainly had a very bad effect on how, uh, lesbians thought about themselves whether whether or not women were willing to, uh, uh, have same sex relationships and certainly how other people thought about, uh, lesbians [00:14:00] and women in same sex relationships. So there's been a very important case in the history of lesbianism in New Zealand.

This page features computer generated text of the source audio. It may contain errors or omissions, so always listen back to the original media to confirm content.

AI Text:September 2023
URL:https://www.pridenz.com/ait_queer_history_parker_hulme_murder.html